Online the common abbreviated acronym ‘IRL’ means ‘in real life’ – a way of referring to the reality that exists out there in the offline world. A popular comment used in digital spaces, ‘go touch grass’, is used to poke fun at those whose reactions online are considered to be the result of being ‘chronically online’ and thus detached from IRL.

Originally, where social media could be used for connection, community and a space to cultivate new ways of being, the idea of social media now is perhaps no longer based in reality. In an article named ‘Social Media is Now Parasocial Media’ Danah Boyd argues that today’s platforms ‘are no longer centred around sociable activities… [i]nstead, most platforms offer us a broadcast medium’.1 The asymmetry in interactions and lack of reciprocity leaves little that is social.

Within this context content creators can endlessly curate their online self, recording as many takes as it requires to achieve an end result that represents them best. In this way social media offers a remarkable opportunity to witness how we relate to different parts of ourselves.

With the external observer in mind, what do we notice about what of us perhaps gets amplified and what gets toned down? In The Psychodynamics of Social Networking Aaron Balick describes how Winnicott’s concept of the ‘false self’, and Jung’s ‘persona’ can be used to explore how we present ourselves online, as both concepts describe a means of managing the space between the internal self and the external other.

While the ‘false self’ can have negative connotations of being fake, Balick explains how the false self can also be understood as taking on ‘the social role so that the true self can carry on being’. Similarly, Jung’s persona utilises a mask, which although distorting is also ‘suited to the individual’ and is more like a partial self than a complete misrepresentation.2

For therapists setting up social media profiles we too necessarily make use of false self/persona. I often see social media accounts from trainees inviting people to join them on their journey to becoming a therapist, or accounts from experienced therapists ‘answering the questions you’re too afraid to ask your therapist’ or decrying the use of social media by other therapists.

In each of these choices is a persona in action offering something that simultaneously holds some truth for the individual (self) while also clearly being conscious of and adapted for the external other.

To be clear, it is not hard to find therapy content online that could be described at best as ethically dubious, at worst harmful, but that’s not the focus of this piece. Instead I want to explore the relationship between therapist and their online self.

‘As a therapist…’

As a marketing tool, social media works best when it is engaging, when the consumer chooses to stay and even actively welcomes the content on offer. For therapists, in the Venn diagram of what they are looking to sell and what the imagined audience might want, three strategies seem to emerge:

Selling answers or reassurance: this content offers psychoeducation, tools and often something reassuring in the form of motivational quotes or validation of feelings and experiences. Depending on the focus, the sell could be some combination of the therapist’s expertise and their ability to be holding.

Selling a peek behind the curtain: this content typically taps into the frustrations, fears and hopes of clients that can often be difficult to bring into the room. It sees the therapist explain cancellation policies, why sessions end on time and what your therapist’s silence means. Notably this content is rarely about the therapist’s personal practice or reasoning but rather offered as general guidance. This distance might help to promote their own trustworthiness and authority.

Selling intimacy: this category ultimately in some way aims to build rapport and invites the audience to imagine the content creator as their own therapist. It typically offers something personal that invites the viewer in, like joining the therapist for their morning coffee, and provides a point-of-view impression of them reacting to different clinical scenarios or a disclosure about their own mental health or past experience that has led them to becoming a therapist. In a field where one of the clearest messages is the importance of the relationship, the sell may ease relational anxiety by offering something of a ‘preview’ as well as warmth and hopefulness.

Any of us who advertise our practice, whether via a directory listing, website or social media account, may use some version of these techniques. However, how we relate to these platforms matters.

Under stress our sense of self may feel more vulnerable or threatened in the face of a client’s frustration, criticism or helplessness, or from the pressure of the sector.

Social media can be immediately available to offer soothing. In response to feeling not good enough our honed persona can create a piece of content foregrounding the professional (external) part of the identity as a therapist, and in doing so ease the pain of the deeply personal (internal) part of this identity that is so essential to a sense of self. In other words, under the guise of social media marketing other vital needs may be covertly played out. Using the ‘outward’ facing themes above, here are some alternative interpretations for what else might be going on behind the mask.

Therapist need

In the case of selling answers or reassurance, whether under pressure to compete and stay up to date or due to something coming up in the room, tolerating uncertainty may give in to shameful feelings like incompetence. In such instances it can be useful to look to our reflection to make us feel solid and certain.

Paula Elkisch in ‘The Psychological Significance of the Mirror’ describes how when someone loses their sense of self or experiences a threat to it, mirrors seem to provide reassurance and protection against the loss.3 Perhaps the same can be said of social media: when our sense of self feels foggy it may be incredibly reassuring to record ourselves offering answers and guidance, to watch this version of us, coherent and clear. In this, a grateful comment section is surely also a boost.

In the case of offering a peek behind the curtain, many of us come into this profession because in some way we care. Many boundaries we have are based on creating a sustainable and facilitative environment so that we can offer this ‘care’ consistently and safely. Sometimes those boundaries can be experienced as clinical, unfair and distinctly uncaring. To be interpreted in this way may leave us feeling deeply misunderstood or wounded. For example, Ferenczi describes the children who very early on need to become psychotherapists, who have had to parent their carers and in turn parent themselves: ‘They thus extend to others the knowledge painfully acquired in coping with their own sufferings, and they become kind and helpful.’4 Where the therapist cannot make use of this tension in the session or the need to be ‘kind and helpful’ cannot be internally contained, it can potentially be acted out and satisfied online.

As for selling intimacy, the relationship with the client has already begun before the client even makes their first contact. Whether this is in how the client relates to the idea of speaking to a therapist (for example, in the context of the Kleinian part-object) or in having chosen to get in touch with us specifically, an idea of who or how we might be has already started to take shape.

Selling previews of the potential relationship might encourage strong, positive transference. Heinz Kohut, in his idea of ‘mirroring’, described the role of the primary carer in reflecting back to the child a sense of self-worth and value. Mirroring helps to build confidence in your sense of potential: the child looks to be ‘the gleam in the mother’s eye’.5 However, where the therapist’s content consistently projects hope and positivity, perhaps the therapist is looking to be the gleam in the client’s eye and to see their own goodness and potential reflected back at them.

Neither good nor bad

This conversation is not about whether it is right or wrong to be on social media as a therapist. As Mary Jo Peebles reflects, ‘The goal of psychotherapy, all turf-battles aside, is to rattle our patient’s certitude about his conclusions.’6 Binaries (and the turf-battles they foster) can offer comforting certitude, but it comes at the cost of exploration and discussion, and in an environment where social media might be used as a marketing tool and as a tool to meet other needs, like regulating the therapist’s sense of self, a discussion is necessary.

This is where the concepts of the false self or the persona, sympathetic mediators as they are, can offer more nuanced frameworks through which to understand the ways in which we might be using social media to bridge the divide between our internal and our external worlds. Once we recognise this we can then pay attention to the kinds of feelings and experiences that might see us reaching for the relief offered by our social media persona. To help us navigate the relationship between the therapist we are and the therapist we wish to be perceived as the following might help:

  • What element of my practice am I hoping to advertise?
  • What part of the content achieves that, and how?
  • What prompted me to create this particular piece of content?
  • Do I feel comfortable putting in the caption that this is an advert, and if not why not?

To borrow Kranzberg’s First Law of Technology, ‘Technology is neither good nor bad; nor is it neutral.’7 The same is true of social media. Fortunately for us as therapists we are likely accustomed to the most interesting question not being ‘Is this right or wrong?’ but rather, ‘What might this mean?’

References

  1. Boyd D. Social media is now parasocial media. Social Media + Society 2026; 12(2).
  2. Balick A. The psychodynamics of social networking: connected-up instantaneous culture and the self. London: Routledge; 2014.
  3. Elkisch P. The psychological significance of the mirror. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 1957; 5(2): 235-244.
  4. Ferenczi S. Child-analysis in the analysis of adults. The International Journal of Psychoanalysis 1931; 12: 468-482.
  5. Kohut H. The restoration of the self. International Universities Press; 1977.
  6. Peebles MJ. When psychotherapy feels stuck. London: Routledge; 2021.
  7. Kranzberg M. Technology and history: ‘Kranzberg’s Laws’. Technology and Culture, 1986; 27(3): 544-560.